Classic Marinara


I’m not sure how I ever made a sports team. Soccer, lacrosse…end list. A serious lack in coordination, balance, and natural athletic ability surely must have been apparent at tryouts. It couldn’t have looked promising when I threw up on the sidewalk after the coaches made me run a mile. Or when I asked if practice could be cut a little shorter because I was “just so sleepy.” Seemed legitimate on my end.

Other than the sports part, I really enjoyed the team. I’d walk off the field feeling like I’d just done the stand-up routine of my life. Always called out for talking too much, laughing too loud, riding my lacrosse stick like a bull, using my soccer ball as a seat on the grass. I’d even get in trouble for making what sounded like animal sounds on the field. Whinnying like a horse, in particular. I think that one was just my laugh.

My main problem with team sports was the uniform. Plainly, that it never fit. Who the hell decided that lacrosse players should wear skirts? And could Umbros at least make wind pants that didn’t look like I’d just strapped royal blue Hefty’s to each leg?  God. 

Maybe my physical discomfort was apparent. The reason why I never started a game. I think it’s safe to say that if my entire team had broken their legs at once, and I was the remaining, able-bodied player, to make one final kick into a wide open goal, my coaches would’ve just called off the game and the season. Probably for the best, as I had a tendency to run away from the ball. Less liability when you don’t make any direct contact, I found.

Plus, I was never clear on the rules. Something something blah blah ‘forty five minutes until you can eat orange wedges.’ That’s what I heard anyway. I barely had enough Sprite in my water bottle to last that first half.

But who knows, maybe it’s positive to try things you’re not necessarily good at. Gives you some humility. Some grace. It’s a wonder that someone with almost no athletic ability can lose 135 lbs. Probably a beautiful testament to the power of just moving in any way you can. I ran, became a runner, quit it like a bad habit, started walking, kept walking. Now I’m striding the streets while listening to podcasts on astronomy 101 like I’m preparing for space travel. Hours upon hours of information on parsecs and light years that I can’t wait to share with… Dee Dee. My pug.

Nowadays I stick to the things I know how to do. Eat cookies. No, and bake them too. Oh, and cook actual food. Because someone told me recently that you people might need some sustenance other than butter, sugar, eggs, and chocolate.  I’m not sure why. But I’ll give you something real nonetheless.

A classic marinara. One that doesn’t require you to be a professional to attempt. And I won’t judge you for your athleticism, your wind pants, or the sound of your laugh. Even if it sounds like a whinny. Especially if it sounds like a whinny.

This sauce is blood red and rich. Luscious and intensely sweet. Caramelizing the onions in olive oil before adding the tomatoes to the saucepan gives it a depth of flavor that is unmatched, and absolutely delightful. Go heavy on the spices and add a spoonful of sugar, as my PJ always does. Ladle it on pasta or just into a bowl… it’s divine.

Classic Marinara

  • 2 TBS olive oil
  • 2-3 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1/2 medium onion, finely diced (about 2/3 cup)
  • 1, 28 oz can ground, peeled or crushed tomatoes (Pastene brand or San Marzano is best)
  • 1 TBS dried oregano
  • 2 tsp dried basil
  • 1/4 tsp each salt and pepper
  • 1-2 TBS sugar
  • fresh basil, a garnish for serving

Add olive oil to a medium saucepan set over medium heat.

Add onions and saute for about 10 minutes, stirring frequently, until the onions have begun to turn a deep caramel color. They will smell faintly sweet.  Do not let them burn. You will want to lower your heat to medium-low after about 5 minutes of cooking. Next, add the garlic and stir constantly for about 30 seconds, until fragrant. If you let the garlic burn even slightly, the sauce will taste bitter so be very careful here.

Add the tomatoes.

Add all remaining ingredients and stir to combine.

Turn the heat back up to medium and let the mixture come to a boil. Reduce the heat to low and let your sauce simmer for as long as you can. At least 30 minutes for an intense, sweet tomato flavor. The longer you let your sauce sit on the stovetop, simmering away, the richer the taste will be. Test the sauce and adjust the seasoning as necessary. Generally, the most common problem you’ll detect in food (of any kind) is either too much or too little salt. Or sugar. Those are the areas you’ll want to play with- adding more or less salt/sugar- for the optimal flavor.

Share:

Subscribe!

71 thoughts on “Classic Marinara

  1. Shanna, like Banana

    And who doesn’t love a classic marinara!?

    I was not and still not great at sports. That’s why I joined the dance team cuz one thing I can do is shake my booty ;)

    Your writing impresses me each and every day Andrea! Seriously..write a book!

    Reply
  2. Lu

    I want pasta for lunch now. Yummy. I was actually good at sports when I was a kid, but now, I can’t do anything. It’s like as I’ve gotten older my coordination and balance have taken a hiatus. I loved hearing about your story.

    Reply
  3. Tracey @ I'm Not Superhuman

    I have zero coordination, too, which is why I never made a sports team. Not that I wanted to. I figure if I had played lacrosse I would have killed myself by day 3 of practice by somehow tripping over the grass.

    This marinara looks great. I never make any because I hate onions and garlic and, go figure, they’re kind of a necessity. Yes, I’m Italian. Shame me.

    Reply
  4. Kelly

    This is awesome…I love classic marinara but it is usually has so much sugar!! I love making my own! And your anticdotes totally cracked me up…I swear you bring words to life and I feel like I am reading an awesome book!

    Reply
  5. Karen

    I agree with the other comments Andrea – write a book! I’ll buy it! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and what keeps me coming back and back again is your clever and witty writing style and your delicious food!

    Reply
  6. Meg

    I’m a little weirded out that I’ve been thinking about finding a good marinara recipe all week and here it is! I will DEFINITELY be testing this out!

    Reply
  7. Erica

    I’ve never made my own marinara and I should just DO it. I’m book marking right now. Josh doesn’t like chunks though…If I grind up the tomatoes, do you think it will impact the flavoring? Let me know. Oh and I bet you looked just awesome in umbros…gosh I had them in every color :)

    Reply
  8. Kate

    This post made me laugh so hard at our failed sports career! What was my excuse!? I love you and PJ’s marinara–equally. xoxo

    Reply
    1. Can You Stay for Dinner

      AAAAHHHH!!! I’m soooo soo happy to see your comment. I love you love you love you! God, at least you’re giving credibility to our insufficiencies as sports players. Thank God we stopped when we did and didn’t mess around with intramurals in college. That would have been disaster zone. I’ll call you tomorrow or Saturday! Thanks for the sweet message, it made me smile a thousand times over!

      Reply
  9. Rose Weiss

    I made the meatballs and this marinara sauce and I have to say, it is the best sauce I have ever had! I served it over the zucchini and summer squash like you did, and I don’t think I will ever buy sauce again! Thanks for sharing =)

    Reply
  10. Veronike

    I let this simmer for about an hour and it was just delicious! I went through 3 spoons because my boyfriend wouldn’t stop licking them!! Can’t wait to have them with your slow cooked meatballs which are taking over my apartment with such bouquet of scents as I type. Yet another great recipe.

    Reply
  11. space waves

    I especially thank you for your thoughtful approach and the amazing help you have given for your professional growth. I would want to take use of this chance to thank you.

    Reply
  12. smashy road

    I especially thank you for your thoughtful approach and the amazing help you have given for your professional growth. I would want to take use of this chance to thank you.

    Reply
  13. AI Interior Design

    Haha, I can totally relate to feeling awkward in team sports! But hey, at least we can all agree on the deliciousness of a good marinara sauce. This recipe sounds amazing, can’t wait to try it!

    Reply
  14. Jamalkneem

    le migliori pillole per l’erezione [url=http://potenzafacile.com/#]sildenafil senza ricetta[/url] kamagra senza ricetta in farmacia

    Reply
  15. WhatsApp GB

    I really enjoyed your blog and the way you broke down the topic. You have a talent for making complex ideas simple and practical. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and making it available for free.

    Reply
  16. Harvey Harvington

    It’s refreshing to see someone embrace their unique sports journey with humor! Have you considered joining a non-competitive team just for the fun of camaraderie? It might be a great way to enjoy the sport without the pressure!

    Reply
  17. Poly Track

    Your reflections on team sports are so relatable! It’s great to hear how you found joy and laughter despite the challenges. Have you thought about trying less traditional sports or activities where you can shine in your own unique way?

    Reply
  18. Lyrics to Song

    It’s great to see the humor in your experiences with sports! It sounds like you brought so much joy to your team. Have you thought about trying a different activity that matches your style a bit better?

    Reply
  19. Basketball Stars

    That’s an inspiring story! It just goes to show that consistency and finding activities you enjoy are key. My own journey with fitness has been… less astronomically inclined! Haha. I find a quick game of Basketball Stars a fun way to get moving and blow off some steam – plus, it’s way less commitment than running! Maybe it could be a good way for you to keep up your momentum when you don’t want to leave the kitchen.

    Reply
  20. احسب عمرك

    احسب عمري مهم في المجال الطبي، إذ يعتمد الأطباء على العمر في تشخيص الحالات وتحديد العلاج المناسب لكل مرحلة عمرية. كما يُستخدم في متابعة نمو الأطفال بشكل دقيق.

    Reply
  21. https://harpersbazaar.kz/goroskop-na-janvar-chto-zhdet-imenno-vas

    Harper’s BAZAAR Kazakhstan features a detailed January horoscope article titled Horoscope for January: What Awaits You Specifically?
    It covers astrological predictions for all 12 zodiac signs amid the retrogrades of Mars and Mercury, offering practical advice on career, love, finances, health, and personal growth—recommending to wrap up old matters early in the month and focus on balance, reflection, and spiritual development later.

    Reply
  22. RBTV77 Plus

    Great platform! I really appreciate how smoothly the features work and how easy it is to navigate through the content. The layout is clean, the information is well-organized, and the overall experience feels user-friendly and engaging. Looking forward to exploring more and seeing future updates!

    Reply
  23. Suika Game

    That marinara sounds absolutely divine! I’m definitely going to try making it this weekend. Speaking of simple pleasures, have you ever played Suika Game? It’s surprisingly addictive and relaxing – a perfect little digital escape after a day of cooking up delicious things like that sauce. You can find it online, it’s a fun little puzzle to unwind with!

    Reply
  24. Texas Roadhouse Menus

    At Texas Roadhouse Menu, we make it easy for you to find everything you need before you even step foot in the restaurant. From juicy steaks to famous sides and desserts, we provide a full breakdown of the menu with updated prices and descriptions. Planning your meal has never been simpler!

    Reply
  25. Grok Video

    Your humor and candidness about your sports experience are refreshing! It’s great that you found joy in the team despite the challenges. Have you considered trying out other activities that suit your strengths more?

    Reply
  26. new.globe.com.ph.simreg

    Great website! I found the information on Globe SIM Registration really helpful and easy to understand. It’s nice to see a clear guide for users in the Philippines who need to register their SIMs quickly and safely. Keep up the good work and thanks for sharing such useful details!

    Reply
  27. Globe Sim Registration

    Great website! I found the information on Globe SIM Registration really helpful and easy to understand. It’s nice to see a clear guide for users in the Philippines who need to register their SIMs quickly and safely. Keep up the good work and thanks for sharing such useful details!

    Reply
  28. Dramaflight

    This website is very well-designed and provides valuable and easy-to-understand information. The content is organized nicely, making it simple for visitors to explore different sections without confusion. I really appreciate the clean layout and smooth browsing experience. It’s clear that a lot of effort is put into keeping everything updated and useful for users. Keep up the great work and continue delivering such quality content!

    Reply
  29. Animate Image AI

    Your reflections on team sports are both relatable and hilarious! It’s great to see the lighter side of trying new things, even when it doesn’t go as planned. Have you found a sport or activity you really enjoy now?

    Reply
  30. Banana Pro

    Your reflections on team sports are so relatable! It’s great that you found joy and camaraderie, even amidst the challenges. Have you considered trying other group activities that might be more your style?

    Reply
  31. Machinery Prices

    This is a really informative and well-presented page. The content is clear, easy to understand, and addresses the topic in a practical way. I especially appreciate the way the information is organized, which makes it simple to find what you’re looking for. Keep up the great work—this is a valuable resource for anyone interested in this subject.

    Reply
  32. Jollibee Menu With Prices

    Great post! I really enjoyed reading this and appreciate the effort you put into explaining everything so clearly. Your insights were both informative and easy to relate to, making it a valuable read. I’m looking forward to more of your blogs — they’re always full of fresh perspectives and practical ideas. Keep up the amazing work!

    Reply
  33. Golden Corral Menu

    Great post! I really enjoyed reading this and found the information very useful. You explained the topic clearly and made it easy to understand. I appreciate the effort you put into creating such detailed and valuable content. Looking forward to more posts like this in the future!

    Reply
  34. Deep Rumors

    Deep Rumors is a digital entertainment platform that covers the latest celebrity gossip, viral news, and pop culture updates. It provides quick, engaging stories to keep readers informed about trending topics in the entertainment world.

    Reply
  35. Animate Image AI

    Your humorous take on sports and teamwork is so relatable! It’s amazing how we can find joy and camaraderie in experiences we’re not naturally good at. Have you considered exploring other activities that might fit your style better?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.